Skip to main content

Jake's Masculinity



Throughout the Sun also Rises Jack is constantly engaged is traditionally masculine activities. No one else in the novel is depicted as masculine and tough as Jake. He is interested in boxing, bullfighting, fishing, etc. Bill and Cohan have similar interests but none of them seem to take it to the same level as Jake, nor our they as outspoken as Jake. Cohan was a boxing champion at Princeton, but he doesn’t seem to bring it up a lot. Bill enjoys fishing similarly to Jake. None of them are “aficionados” when it comes to bullfighting like Jake. Cohan is actually a wimp when it comes to bullfighting (according to Jake).  

All of this hyper-masculinity makes it seem like Jake is trying to overcompensate for something. Obviously, we know that he has a problem “down stairs”.  He has a problem with “manhood” and he is trying to show everyone he is still a man. He still likes manly activities because he is still THE man. However, we never really find out what Jake was like before his injury. Was he also very masculine? Or was it more toned down? Jake seems like the type of person who would always be interested in things like boxing and other manly activities. However, I think that after his accident he hyped these ups to hide his insecurities. Do you think Jake was always so “manly” or was that something that developed after his accident?


Comments

  1. Smita NairSeptember 28, 2018 at 8:33 PM

    Good point. I'd assumed that Jake's passions for fishing and bullfighting had existed before his issue had, but his hard-boiled persona exists as a result of that issue. However, I think it's Jake's newfound push into toxic masculinity that leads him to insult Cohn so frequently. No one confident in themselves and their masculinity insults someone to that degree. Although this could just be because he's so bigoted.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Amina GSeptember 28, 2018 at 9:47 PM

    I agree with your analysis. Jake does seem like he's probably always been "manly", but that that manliness was over-exaggerated after the accident. As we've discussed in class, his harsh judgement of Cohn and other men says a lot about his insecurities. Jake seems to harbor quite a bit of resentment towards men who he thinks are more 'masculine' than him because of his issue. This causes him to hyperbolize how masculine he really thinks he is, thinking that this amplification will cover up his issues and hide his problem

    ReplyDelete
  3. Neha AluruSeptember 30, 2018 at 9:22 PM

    I think that Jake has always had an interest in bullfighting, fishing, and boxing. However, to overcompensate for his "lack of manliness", I think Jake copes by being overly critical of people like Cohn and acting like he doesn't have a care in the world, especially when it comes to discussing Brett in front of others. Because we see a softer and kinder version of Jake when he is with Brett, it makes me think that Jake was probably not as "manly" before the war.

    ReplyDelete
  4. KevinOctober 1, 2018 at 8:54 AM

    I'm not really sure. It seems possible that he began following bullfighting seriously after the war. I think he definitely was a fan of all of these sports beforehand, because he knows how to fish well. At the same time, it's possible that before the war, he wasn't as much of an aficionado for bullfighting, or any of his other manly interests, as he is now. It definitely seems over emphasized, particularly in that he criticizes people who aren't very masculine--i think he developed this tendency after the war.

    ReplyDelete
  5. FaizahOctober 5, 2018 at 12:41 PM

    I like how you brought up the point that we never got to know what Jake was like before the war, and before his injury. I imagine that Jake was probably always into bull fighting and boxing. However, I do agree that after the war he probably amplified and tried to be more vocal about his interests in things that are seen as more masculine in order to compensate for his injury.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Twisted Love in Song of Solomon

In Song of Solomon , there is the idea that love has to be twisted. Every example of love in the book depicts love as an ultra-violent force that controls and ruins lives. However, I think that the book also shows that love has to be “wrong” in order to exist. Love must be abnormal, and it won’t work out. Throughout the story Ruth is described as having a perverted relationship with her father. From what we are told, she got great satisfaction from that connection. Macon describes his wife as “laying next to him. Naked as a yard dog, kissing him.” Ruth even says that her father was “the only person who ever really cared whether I lived or died”. That even despite this unnatural pairing there was still a very intense love. Then there is Hagar and Milkman. First Milkman and Hagar are cousins, which even back then was taboo. The rest of the town also considers this relationship to be wrong. “Ought to be shamed, the two of them. Cousins .” However, this is the only we...
6 comments
Read more

Clarissa through the People around Her

It seems while throughout the book there is this persistent idea that Clarissa Dalloway is a bit of a snob and stuck up. Most of the point is from Clarissa’s point of view. The other main character is Septimus (along with Rezia) who never directly interacts with Clarissa. A lot of the other characters comment on the personality and appearance of Clarissa. All of the characters give a biased interpretation of the world. The book goes directly through their innermost thoughts so none of the characters can truly be trusted. This is especially seen through Septimius’s PTSD/Schizophrenic mind where a dog literally turns into a man. Although we can’t trust any of the characters completely a lot of them point out how snobbish and uptight Clarissa is. An obvious example would be Peter who seems to constantly criticize Clarissa (although he does “love” Clarissa and appreciate her in his own way). Another pretty obvious character is Miss Kilman who pities Clarissa partly f...
6 comments
Read more

Mrs. Dalloway’s Drama Filled Day

While we are still reading through Mrs. Dalloway (being only 40-50 pages in right now) I find it interesting (to quote Howie) how a lot of things already seem to have happened. I know that Clarissa just started her day and is walking around and that isn’t too important, but a lot of things seem to be happening on this day. First of all, she has just recovered from a serious case of influenzas (something we talked about in class) and that this is her first real outing. Mrs. Dalloway seems to really be reflecting on her life. Then she hears a motor car backfire and “might” have seen the queen or some other important royalty. If I had almost seen royalty (or a celebrity which is the modern equivalent) I would definitely consider that the highlight of my month but then immediately afterword Mrs. Dalloway sees skywriting. Skywriting would have been new and exciting for that time and Mrs. Dalloway seems to also have been awed by this. After Mrs. Dalloway gets home her former lover (or ...
8 comments
Read more